Skip to content
- Originality and Novelly
- Should the submitted paper introduce new ideas or provide new insights into the field?
- Has this research contributed significantly to existing knowledge.
- The results of this research improve or challenge existing understanding.
- Depth and Rigor of Research
- The submission of the paper is based on a strong theoretical framework.
- The manuscript must be comprehensive and thorough in the research methodology used.
- The data used in the study sufficiently support the findings presented.
- Clarity and Structure of Writing
- The paper is written clearly and concisely.
- It has arguments and findings that are presented logically and well-structured.
- The use of language and terminology is appropriate and understandable to the intended audience.
- Significance and Potential Impact
- Has findings that have a significant impact on practice or research in the related field.
- Contains and has findings and practical implications.
- The results of the submitted research can influence policy or decision-making in the field.
- Adequacy of Literature and References
- The manuscript refers to relevant and up-to-date literature.
- The author demonstrates a good understanding of existing related research.
- Adequate research results and discussion of previous work.
- Research Ethics
- The submitted research results meet the required ethical standards.
- Have appropriate ethical approval, if involving human or animal subjects.
- Data Presentation and Visualization
- Tables, graphs, and diagrams used effectively can support the text. The resulting data visualization is clear and easy to understand.
- Conformity to Conference Theme
- The submitted paper manuscript is relevant to the theme and topics raised in the conference.
- The paper manuscript can make a high contribution that can support the objectives of the conference.
- Writing and Editing Quality
- The submitted manuscript is free from grammatical and spelling errors. The format and writing style of the submitted manuscript are consistent and in accordance with the conference guidelines.